Eddie & Anthony's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

My husband picked up our pizza, ziti and rolls. Pizza was ok very light on the toppings. Ziti was only noodles and cheese not a drop of sauce and the rolls were burnt black on top. Too many other pizza resturants in the area to serve such poor quality food.

I ordered take out from here a couple of weeks ago for my kids and I. I ordered the family deal - two large pizzas, 12 garlic rolls, two salads, a two liter. One of our pizzas, the one for my kids, was almost completely burnt. The other one was "okay". (This is the second time they burned our pizza. We took it back the first time to re-make it.) This time, however, I wasn't making a trip back, and dragging my kids to go get a better cooked pizza. I apologized to my kids profusely for it, since they don't like their food at all, ad once in a while I like to order pizza from them and get real pizza food, instead of "fast food pizza" like pizza hut or something. They were very forgiving and great sports about it all, and ate the pizza anyways, but not without reminding me that they would've rather had Pizza Hut or something else like it. I promised them I wouldn't get Eddie and Anthony's again. The garlic rolls were literally, "old bread" or "stale", with the garlic being old, dry, and "crumby", and the salad lettuce was definitely not fresh. I had tasted and seen enough, so I ended up throwing out the salads, as I didn't even want to know how that was. The only thing I know for sure is that they couldn't mess up on the two liter soda! I called the next day, and was told the manager's name was Luke, then Will got on the phone and said he was the manager. Who knows. He offered me a $10 discount, but I won't order food my kids can't get fresh when I'm going to be spending about $30 only to have to probably throw most of it out.

I've eaten in and taken out food from them many a time & never had a problem. Their calzones & pizza are fantastic & if you want really good garlic rolls try theirs(who thought garlic rolls would make a yummy breakfast). While I haven't tried their dinners, I love their marinara sauce that comes with the calzones & the sauce they use on their pizza is so much better than the typical pizza place. While ordering a pizza one day I mentioned that I can only do light onions because white onions are too strong & I wished it was possible to get red onions since they are mild. Would you believe they said no problem - - they use red onions in their salads & it was no problem to use red instead of white onions. And if you are a pineapple lover like me, they have the best tasting pineapple I've ever had... And I do mean ever!

I ordered a ham with extra cheese pizza, called hubs to pick it up... he got it home it was peperoni. I called and told them and they said "come pick up your pizza again" so i did. when i picked it up it was only cheese, then the manager argued with me that I only ordered cheese. I threw it on the table and walked out -- I HATE BEING CALLED A LIAR BY SOME STUPID PERSON THAT CANT EVEN MAKE A HAM AND EXTRA CHEESE PIZZA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!