Mustachio's Pizzeria

New to New York and today had my first real slice of pizza. It was soooo good. Just like the oversized, floppy crusted, stringy cheesy pizza you see in movies, this was everything I imagined and more. No more big chain restaurant pizza for me. Service was also great. I will definitely go back.

Definitely would not recommend. i ordered a chicken finger dinner (which is 7.95) and the fingers are tiny, definitely not living up to buffalos reputation for hugs chicken fingers (everywhere else we go) very disappointing. tried them one more time since the last time they argued with me over not delivering one of my items. took 10 minutes of arguing with girl on phone then they delivered my cold food another half hour later. very unimpressed and will not be ordering there again. save your $$!!

Super tasty pizza! The basic pepperoni is greasy and terrific!! The subs there are some of the best around- I quite enjoy their italian sausage sub!

oh my goodness - the very best turkey club i've had!!! We have been there 3 times and each time was fantastic!

After years of looking for a consistant "good" fish fry, we have finally found the place. Homemade salads, large portions, and just plain yummy! A must try!