Find a business

        HomeNYAmityvilleThrift Shops

        Thrift Shops in Amityville, NY

        Amvets - Thrift Shops

        1. Amvets

        Thrift Shops
        Website
        (631) 699-2412
        View all 5 Locations
        1179 Sunrise Hwy
        Copiague, NY 11726
        Church Attic - Thrift Shops

        2. Church Attic

        Thrift Shops
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        48 Years
        in Business
        (631) 264-4555
        47 Broadway
        Amityville, NY 11701
        CLOSED NOW
        Montauk Buy and Sell - Gold, Silver & Platinum Buyers & Dealers

        3. Montauk Buy and Sell

        Thrift ShopsGold, Silver & Platinum Buyers & DealersJewelers
        Years in Business Icon
        12 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 450-4040
        654 W Montauk Hwy
        Lindenhurst, NY 11757
        CLOSED NOW

        From Business: WE Buy gold silver platinum diamonds watches tools electronics and more. We serv all Long Island, we are located in the Town of Babylon , Village of Lindenhurst.…

        Church Attic - Second Hand Dealers

        4. Church Attic

        Thrift ShopsSecond Hand Dealers
        (631) 264-4555
        47 S Bay Ave
        Amityville, NY 11701
        All You Need Is Thrift - Second Hand Dealers

        5. All You Need Is Thrift

        Thrift ShopsSecond Hand Dealers
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 450-4433
        148 W Hoffman Ave
        Lindenhurst, NY 11757
        CLOSED NOW
        Blessingdales Thrift Shop - Second Hand Dealers

        6. Blessingdales Thrift Shop

        Thrift ShopsSecond Hand DealersConsignment Service
        (1)
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 842-0086
        1148 Sunrise Hwy
        Copiague, NY 11726
        OPEN NOW

        Love this store and the people that work there"

        Goodwill Stores - Thrift Shops

        7. Goodwill Stores

        Thrift ShopsResale ShopsConsignment Service
        Website
        (516) 795-0237
        View all 5 Locations
        814 Hicksville Rd
        North Massapequa, NY 11758
        OPEN NOW
        St. John's Thrift Shoppe - Thrift Shops

        8. St. John's Thrift Shoppe

        Thrift Shops
        (631) 888-8571
        42 E John St
        Lindenhurst, NY 11757
        CLOSED NOW
        4U It's New - Thrift Shops

        9. 4U It's New

        Thrift Shops
        (516) 509-7715
        Dix Hills, NY 11746

        From Business: 4U It's NEW is focused on the ECO friendly and Budget friendly process of reselling and consigning upscale fashions.

        T & F Salvage Inc - Thrift Shops

        10. T & F Salvage Inc

        Thrift ShopsCharitiesConsignment Service
        (516) 756-5171
        301 Main St
        Farmingdale, NY 11735
        New to You Shoppe - Thrift Shops

        11. New to You Shoppe

        Thrift ShopsSecond Hand Dealers
        (516) 752-2181
        401 Main St
        Farmingdale, NY 11735
        CLOSED NOW
        Kiss Consignment - Consignment Service

        12. Kiss Consignment

        Thrift ShopsResale ShopsConsignment Service
        Years in Business Icon
        15 Years
        in Business
        (631) 979-5477
        Commack, NY 11725
        CLOSED NOW
        The Salvation Army Thrift Store West Babylon, NY - Charities

        13. The Salvation Army Thrift Store West Babylon, NY

        Thrift ShopsCharitiesSocial Service Organizations
        Website
        (800) 728-7825
        View all 8 Locations
        227 Little East Neck Rd
        West Babylon, NY 11704
        CLOSED NOW

        From Business: When you donate goods to The Salvation Army, those items are then sold at our Family Stores. Proceeds are used to fund our Adult Rehabilitation Centers, where…

        Help For People, Inc. - Charities

        14. Help For People, Inc.

        Thrift ShopsCharitiesClothing Stores
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        12 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (631) 903-2480
        93 Marine St
        Farmingdale, NY 11735
        CLOSED NOW
        American Family Thrift Car Donation - Charities

        15. American Family Thrift Car Donation

        Thrift ShopsCharities
        (516) 586-6756
        375 Fulton St
        Farmingdale, NY 11735
        Once Upon A Child - Children & Infants Clothing

        16. Once Upon A Child

        Resale ShopsChildren & Infants ClothingBaby Accessories, Furnishings & Services
        (3)
        Website
        (516) 579-4200
        1089 Hicksville Rd
        Seaford, NY 11783
        CLOSED NOW

        After reading the other negative review I was hesitant to go here but had items wanted to sell so figured I would try anyway and expected the worse. However! I have no clue…

        Open Door Thrift Shop - Second Hand Dealers

        17. Open Door Thrift Shop

        Thrift ShopsResale ShopsSecond Hand Dealers
        Years in Business Icon
        58 Years
        in Business
        (516) 221-2222
        2142 Jackson Ave
        Seaford, NY 11783
        CLOSED NOW
        Thrifting With Style - Thrift Shops

        18. Thrifting With Style

        Thrift ShopsResale ShopsSecond Hand Dealers
        (7)
        Coupons
        Years in Business Icon
        9 Years
        in Business
        (631) 940-6187
        1350 Deer Park Ave
        North Babylon, NY 11703
        CLOSED NOW
        $5.00

        I visited this store and thought for a moment I was in a quaint antique shop in the Hamptons.There are several pieces to die for. I purchased one and the thing that struck me…

        One More Time Ltd - Resale Shops

        19. One More Time Ltd

        Thrift ShopsResale Shops
        (631) 320-3835
        116 Mahan St
        West Babylon, NY 11704
        Joy Thrift Store - Resale Shops

        20. Joy Thrift Store

        Thrift ShopsResale ShopsSecond Hand Dealers
        (516) 830-8030
        329 Nassau Rd
        Roosevelt, NY 11575
        OPEN NOW
        Romano Gatland - Thrift Shops

        21. Romano Gatland

        Thrift Shops
        Website
        (631) 226-7700
        1 Huntington Quad
        Melville, NY 11747
        4U It's New - Thrift Shops

        22. 4U It's New

        Thrift Shops
        (516) 509-7715
        4 Wentworth Dr
        Dix Hills, NY 11746
        Unitarian Thrift Shop - Thrift Shops

        24. Unitarian Thrift Shop

        Thrift Shops
        (516) 223-3974
        22 Merrick Ave
        Merrick, NY 11566
        Unitarian Thrift Shop - Thrift Shops

        25. Unitarian Thrift Shop

        Thrift ShopsConsignment Service
        Website
        (516) 223-3974
        22 W Merrick Rd
        Freeport, NY 11520
        CLOSED NOW
        Urban Thrift - Thrift Shops

        26. Urban Thrift

        Thrift Shops
        (631) 270-4821
        62 Commerce Dr
        Farmingdale, NY 11735
        Tri County Unique Bazaar - Thrift Shops

        27. Tri County Unique Bazaar

        Thrift Shops
        Website
        (516) 520-7340
        3041 Hempstead Tpke
        Levittown, NY 11756
        OPEN NOW
        Society Of St. Vincent De Paul - Thrift Shops

        28. Society Of St. Vincent De Paul

        Thrift ShopsSocial Service OrganizationsCharities
        Website
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (516) 822-3132
        249 Broadway
        Bethpage, NY 11714
        CLOSED NOW
        Goodwill Mini Shop & Donation Drop - Charities

        30. Goodwill Mini Shop & Donation Drop

        Thrift ShopsCharities
        Website
        (516) 206-3984
        1163 Merrick Ave
        Merrick, NY 11566
        CLOSED NOW

        From Business: An attended donation center with a small shopping space attached featuring accessories, home decor, and select accessories.

        HomeNYAmityvilleThrift Shops
        About Search Results

        YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

        Places Near Amityville, NY with Thrift Shops

        More Types of Second Hand Stores in Amityville

        Consignment ServiceSwap ShopsResale ShopsPawnbrokersJunk Dealers